Software Evaluation Forum

Welcome to the University of Calgary Software Evaluation Forum. The purpose of this web page is to provide educators with a database of educational software titles to evaluate. Each software title here is evaluated on a number of criteria pertaining to its educational value. Detailed descriptions and lesson ideas for each program are also available.

Although we try very hard to keep up with the latest titles coming out, we will invariably miss far more that we evaluate. This page depends on you to provide descriptions and ratings of software you have used successfully in the past. Please take the time to fill out the software evaluation form at the bottom of this document if you know of packages not mentioned on this site.


Software Evaluations


Software TitleDescription
Grade
Subject
System Reqs.
Age Level
Interface
Ed. Val
Graph Qual
Ease of Use
Learn. Curve
Adj. Dif.
Overall Rating
Civilization Build your civilization from scratch.
10+
ss
386
15+
G/M
3
8
7
Med
Yes
6.8
The Incredible MachineSolve a puzzle by using various devices
3+
ph
386
8+
G/M
5
10
9
Low
No
7.8
Castle of Dr. BrainA collection of puzzles in a haunted castle
3+
ma
386
8+
G/M/K
7
9
9
Low
No
8
EncartaAn encyclopedia of various facts
2+
all
486/CD
6+
G/M/K
9
6
8
Low
N/A
8.25
AscendancyA game of space conquest
10+
so
486/CD
15+
G/M
2
9
7
Med
Yes
6.8



Legend

Subject

Abbr.

Subject

Abbr.

Interface

Abbr.

Accountingac Frenchfr Graphical EnvironmentG
Artart Geometryge Mouse ControlledM
Biologybi Mathma Keyboard ControlledK
Chemistrych Physicsph
Computerco Social Studiesso
Dramadr Trigonometrytr
Englishen


Detailed Software Descriptions


Civilization

Introduction

Civilization is a game of global discovery and exploration. The purpose is to build your one unit of settlers into a prosperous, happy and powerful civilization spanning the globe. The game is played by building up research, production, and population, accumulating new cities and developing the land. Other civilizations will eventually be encountered and will need to be dealt with through the use of diplomacy or force. Winning is accomplished by simply surviving until the year 2080 AD. At that time, you will be judged on how well you ruled and compared to actual historical leaders.

Subjects Covered

Civilization has brief descriptions of various City and Civilization Advances that the player can achieve through out the game in a module called the Civilopedia, or on-line encyclopedia. An example of a Civilization Advance would be Navigation: To achieve it, your civilization must first discover Mapmaking and Astronomy. If the user wanted to find out more about Navigation before choosing to research it, they would look it up in the Civilopedia:

A further screen can then be brought up to find out the exact benefits, in terms of game advantage, that this advance would provide:

Lesson Ideas

Civilization can cement ideas learned about ancient civilizations with interesting descriptions and fun game play. It should be combined with a course on ancient history, or one stressing the advantages and drawbacks of today's political governing systems. The game supports several different styles of government ranging from anarchy to communism to democracy. Each system has definite benefits that can be explored and understood through game play.

Another approach would be to teach the students the basic elements needed for a civilization to survive and prosper, and have them attempt to implement those ideas in the game. Some elements that should be stressed are:

Encyclopedia Encarta

Introduction

Microsoft® Encarta® 96 Encyclopedia, the award-winning multimedia encyclopedia, combines comprehensive, up-to-date content with the most modern technological advancements -- creating an engaging and enjoyable learning experience students of any age. Encarta Encyclopedia's interactive design and features make it easy to find the information you need -- or to explore new topics and ideas.

Subjects Covered

This application covers all subject matters. Like a regular encyclopedia, the information that is presented by the package is very basic and generally provides a brief but descriptive overview of the subject in question. Because of the multimedia aspect of the application, it provides visual and audio aspects to learning.

Powerful Fact Finding

The Pinpointer is a powerful search tool that lets you find topics quickly and easily. Look up one of the encyclopedia's more than 26,000 articles in one step, or narrow your topic search down by key word, category, media, time, or place.

Powerful Learning Tools

Encarta Encyclopedia lets you learn through experimentation. With InterActivities, you discover a variety of topics from world music and art to natural wonders, orbits, nutrition, and languages. Each lesson provides you with information, and some ask you to solve a puzzle with the information you learned.

Lesson Ideas

Because Encyclopedia Encarta is easy to use and provides students with a broad range of information, this application can be used as a researching tool. A lesson plan can be developed where the students are to use the software application for a research paper. The students can pick any topic that Encarta provides and write a 1-2 page summary about that topic. The main purpose in this lesson is to get the students to use the application and it will also demonstrate the vast amounts of information that the application encompasses.


Link, Oh The Links!


CSR Software Evaluation Policies

CAMLI Corporation

The Software Learning Zone

Internet Reference Library of Educational Software

Cross Educational Software

The Educational Software Cooperative

Educational Software for Mathematics

CDROM Software Archive

Educational Software Institute

Language Arts Lesson Plans

ERIC (Educational Resources Information Center) Lesson Plans


Software Evaluation Form


Name: Occupation:
Software Title: Description:
Grade: Subject:
Sys. Reqs: Age Level:
Interface: Ed. Value:
Graphics Qual.: Ease of Use:
Learning Curve: Adjustable Difficulty:

Click here to submit your evaluation when you are done: