HTML draft - clarification of quoted string processing

cheung@eplrx7.es.dupont.com (Bryan Cheung)

Mail folder: WWW Talk Oct 93-present
Next message: ellson@hotsand.att.com: "Re: X Mosaic, FTP and PASV"
Previous message: Jim Davis: "HTTP MIme content-type parameters"
Reply: Dave_Raggett: "Re: HTML draft - clarification of quoted string processing"

Date: Fri, 3 Dec 93 10:48:17 EST
Message-id: <9312031548.AA23860@eplrx7.es.duPont.com>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
To: www-talk@nxoc01.cern.ch
From: cheung@eplrx7.es.dupont.com (Bryan Cheung)
Subject: HTML draft - clarification of quoted string processing

I may just be blind, but I don't see a place in the HTML spec which 
describes what is supposed to happen to special characters inside quoted
strings. Consider an HTML statement such as:

<form method=post action="/htbin-post/banner hello > foobar">
...form goes here
</form>

My question relates to how the i/o redirection character (or any special
character) is to be treated when used within quotes inside of a standard
HTML directive. Should special characters be completely protected when
quoted inside of a directive?? Does it make sense to specify that escapes
such as &gt; be used within quoted strings? Where should this go in the
spec? (I looked for it, and can't find it - please point me there if I
missed it.

On a related note, the above question was generated by some strange
behavior I discovered in the following abuse of NCSA httpd, and X Mosaic:

HTML file:
===========================================================
<pre>
<inc srv "|echo Backslash escapes:">
<inc srv "| echo greater than: \>">
<inc srv "| echo less than: \<">
<inc srv "|echo HTML amper/semi escapes:">
<inc srv "| echo greater than: &gt;">
<inc srv "| echo less than: &lt;">
</pre>
===========================================================

Source received by X Mosaic:
===========================================================
<pre>
Backslash escapes:

greater than:
">
less than: <
HTML amper/semi escapes:

greater than:

less than:

</pre>
===========================================================


A few questions:

1) Why are extra newlines generated after each <inc srv "|blah">
   directive?

2) Why doesn't \> work when \< seems to.

3) Does this happen only to me?


I am using XMosaic 2.0 and httpd 1.0a5 under AIX 3.2.4.


                              -- Bryan Cheung
                                 cheung@eplrx7.es.dupont.com